Fiber Laser vs. CO2 Laser vs. Diode Laser: 3 Types of Laser Engravers and Cutters 

Laser engravers and cutters are commonly used and available nowadays. Many people use them to create all kinds of crafts and projects to make homes sweeter, use them as gifts for friends and family, or sell them online to have an extra income.

Among all laser machines, fiber laser engravers, CO2 laser engravers and diode laser engravers are the three types of laser engravers used by most people. But if you get confused about the differences between them, and which laser is perfect for your laser engraving and cutting projects or business, you are not alone.

All these types of laser engravers have distinct characteristics, pros, and cons, and they are used for different purposes.

What Is a Diode Laser Engraver?

Diode laser engravers are pretty popular on the market because they are available at a reasonable price.

A diode is a semiconductor that is made by combining p-type and n-type material. One side of the diode is p-type, and the other side is n-type.

The p-type and n-type materials are joined together, and the junction is called a p-n junction. Laser beams are emitted from this junction.

After applying the potential difference at the ends of the diode, electrons from the n-type travel towards the p-type, and the holes in the p-type travel towards the n-type, which works similar to LEDs, but the output is very intense and coherent, consisting of a single frequency. Multiple laser diodes are used for high intensity, which is commonly called a diode bank.

The beams coming from the diodes are deflected using mirrors and passed through a converging lens. They converge the laser beams into a very fine spot which produces intense heat. The material at which the laser beams fall vaporizes quickly. 

What Is a CO2 Laser Engraver?

Named after the gas used inside the discharge tube, CO2 laser engravers were the earliest gas lasers that were invented in 1964. They have now become one of the most common types of laser engravers on the market and are widely used by small businesses. 

In a CO2 laser engraver or cutter, a discharge tube is filled with numerous gasses (also known as gas-filled tube), but CO2 is in the highest proportion, which is why the laser is called the CO2 laser. The other gasses inside the discharge tube are hydrogen, helium, oxygen, nitrogen, and xenon.

There are two electrodes at the ends of the discharge tube. When a high voltage is applied to the electrodes, the nitrogen molecules are excited. In the excited state, the molecules are in a metastable vibrational state. These molecules excite the CO2 molecules present in the discharge tube. When the excited CO2 molecules come in contact with the helium molecules, intense energy is released in the form of light or photons. These photons are the laser beams that are used to cut and engrave materials.

The light or laser beams that come out of the tube are pretty powerful. They instantly increase the temperature of the object that comes in contact and vaporize the material in no time. 

What is a Fiber Laser Engraver? 

Fiber lasers are the most powerful and thus the most expensive of all types. Fiber lasers are a very new technology compared to CO2 lasers and diode lasers. Fiber lasers also use a bank of diodes to create laser beams. We have already explained how laser beams are created in a laser diode. The same thing happens here, but the laser beams are amplified, which ultimately increases the power of the laser.

These lasers are different from simple diode lasers because they have an amplification system. The laser beams travel through fiberglass or fiber optic cables, which amplifie the laser beams due to the presence of rare earth metals.

The amplified laser beams are highly powerful. They are directed towards a converging lens. The final laser coming out from the converging lens is capable of cutting metals.

They are much more powerful than CO2 and diode lasers. The output power of fiber lasers is around 2,000-4,000 watts. Industrial fiber lasers are more powerful and have an output rating of more than 10,000 watts. 

Fiber lasers are not suitable for DIY and small businesses because they are very expensive. Mostly, they are used to cutting metals. And these lasers have a long lifespan and last a lot longer than CO2 lasers.

Diode Laser Engravers vs CO2 Laser Engravers vs Fiber Laser Engravers: Which Laser to Choose? 

1. Materials the Lasers Can Cut and Engrave

The decision to select a type of laser depends on the materials you want to engrave and cut and what the laser machine can do. First of all, if a laser can cut certain materials, it can also engrave them. But if a laser is engraving certain materials, it is not necessary it will be able to cut them. For cutting, high power is needed compared to engraving.

a. Materials Compatible with Dioder Laser Engravers

If you want a laser machine for crafting or starting a small business, a diode laser is a suitable option as it can cut and engrave a wide range of materials we commonly use. Diode laser machines can easily cut wood, plywood, acrylic(opaque), cardboard, paper, and leather. These are the common materials that almost all laser diode machines can cut according to their power.

The materials that can be engraved by a diode laser engraver are wood, plywood, acrylic, paper, leather, metals, glass, ceramics, and a few more materials.

b. Materials Compatible with CO2 Laser Engravers

CO2 laser machines are better than diode laser machines in terms of cutting materials. They can cut and engrave a broader range of materials. And due to its 10,640nm wavelength being absorbed the majority of non-metals, CO2 laser engravers can work on almost all non-metals.

A CO2 laser can cut wood, plywood, MDF, acrylic (all colors), foam, paper, cardboard, leather, plastics, fabric, and rubber. The materials that a CO2 laser can engrave are acrylic (all colors), wood, plywood, MDF, leather, plastic, fabric, rubber, brick, ceramics, bone, and coated metals.

c. Fiber Laser Engravers

Fiber laser machines can cut and engrave most metals and some non-metals. It cuts and marks metals that other laser machines cannot do. These machines are very powerful, so they can easily cut a wide range of metals. But primarily, these lasers are used for marking and engraving. They can engrave aluminum, brass, copper, ceramics, tungsten, chrome, painted metal, fiberglass, carbon fiber, nickel, plastics, wood, rubber, silver, gold, stainless steel, and synthetic leather.

2. Laser Power

Beginners need to understand a few things while considering the power of a laser machine. There are three types of power ratings mentioned for laser machines. The three types are laser optical/output power, laser electric power, and machine power. 

Machine power refers to the input power of the machines. It does not represent the power of a laser. The second one is the laser electric power, which is the input electrical energy taken by the laser module. The power is related to the laser module, but it does not represent the ability of the laser to engrave and cut an object. However, it can be used to understand the electricity consumption of the laser module.

The most important power is the laser optical/output power. It is the power that shows the ability to cut and engrave materials. The laser coming out of the module has optical power, and buyers need to see this power to understand what a laser machine can do.

The machine power rating is always the highest, and then comes the laser electrical power, and finally the laser optical power. For instance, a diode laser machine has an optical power of 10W, electric power of 40W, and machine power of 60W. Beginners get confused between laser electrical power and optical power. Some companies also scam people by telling them the electrical power instead of optical power. Thus, you always need to see the optical power of the machine for comparison.

a. Optical Power of Diode Laser Engravers

Diode lasers have the lowest optical power compared to other types of laser engravers. They are typically 5-40W. However, they can cut and engrave all materials we have discussed. Even this low power is suitable for small businesses. If the power is low, then there will be more passes required to cut or engrave the materials.

xTool has introduced the world's most powerful diode laser module with 40W optical power. The module is very powerful, which can cut up to 18mm wood in one pass. It does the job quickly and with high precision. It increases the efficiency of engraving and cutting of a diode laser engraver.

b.  Optical Power of CO2 Laser Engravers

CO2 laser engravers are more powerful than diode lasers. They can cut more objects as the laser beams provide more heat energy. The optical power of CO2 lasers ranges from 40W to 300W, making the machine are excellent for cutting and engraving more materials.

c.  Optical Power of Fiber Laser Engravers

Fiber laser machines are ultimately powerful. They can cut metals, so you can assume how powerful they are. These laser machines typically have optical power of 2,000 to 4,000 watts, which is about 100 times the power of CO2 and diode lasers. Industrial fiber laser machines are more powerful. The power rating could be more than 10,000 watts.

3) Lifespan

Lifespan is another critical thing to consider while buying laser machines. For instance, if the lifespan of a laser machine is less, then you need to buy replacement parts or a new machine. Consequently, it becomes expensive. 

The lifespan of fiber lasers is the best. The expected lifespan is about 100,000 hours, which is commendable. But these machines are pretty expensive; the upfront cost is relatively high. The diode lasers come next. They have an expected life of 25,000 to 50,000 hours. It is excellent for small businesses as it has an excellent lifespan and reasonable price. The lifespan of CO2 lasers is the lowest, lasting for 5,000 to 8,000 hours. Therefore, you need to replace their parts often or replace the whole machine. In the end, it becomes a bit more expensive than diode lasers.

Simply put, 

Lifespan: Fiber Lasers > Diode Lasers > CO2 Lasers

4) Speed

The speed of a laser is directly proportional to the optical power. The higher the power, the higher the speed. Thus, we can say that fiber lasers have the highest speed as their power is 100 times more than CO2 lasers. Then, there come CO2 lasers. They are slower than fiber lasers but faster than diode lasers. Diode lasers come in the last, but it does not mean they take a lot of time. They are the slowest in comparison, but they can cut and engrave at a fast pace. They can cut an 8mm thick plywood at the speed of 1-3mm per second, which is quite fast.

comparison of engraving speed between 40w and 20w diode laser engraver

5) Price

The final and most crucial factor is the price. If you want to start a laser engraving business at a low cost, there is nothing better than a diode laser engraver. It is available at a very reasonable price, and the lifespan is excellent. So, it gives you an excellent ROI quickly.

Typically, diode lasers are available in the range of $700-$1500. For a business, you might need some extra attachments, such as rotary attachment and air assist. CO2 lasers are in the middle. A typical CO2 laser will cost about $3,000 to $4,500. In addition, the lifespan of a CO2 laser is quite less, so you need to keep that in mind. The most expensive laser on the market is a fiber laser. It is expensive as it is the newest of all and can cut metals as well as some non-metals. The price ranges from $15,000 to $20,000. The cost of an industrial fiber laser is a lot more than that. For small businesses, fiber lasers are a big no.

Best Diode Laser Engraver and Cutter

xTool S1, the latest machine in our lineup, currently stands as the most powerful enclosed diode laser cutter available. Its flagship variant features a 40W diode laser module, comparable in power to what most CO2 laser machines offer. It can cut through 18mm of wood in a single pass.

The S1 also excels in the engraving segment, being quicker than most diode cutters available — an engraving speed of 600mm/s allows it to finish engraving jobs within minutes. It can cut and engrave multiple common materials including wood, paper, leather, fabric, and opaque acrylic. The engraving list is even longer, including dark glass, painted metal, brick, shale, and marble.

For engracing metal and plastic, a dedicated 2W IR Laser (1064nm) is also offered. Besides the top variant, two smaller variants, 20W and 10W, are available for hobbyists and DIYers.

The interior of the S1 is quite spacious, featuring a bed size of 23.93 by 15.16 inches, which is 40% more than what competitors offer. This space is ample for most DIY projects. Work expansion is also possible, thanks to AutoPassthrough™ Technology. There’s a passthrough slot that allows for working on objects up to 118 inches long.

Most machines feature a camera system for mapping designs onto the material. The S1 steps ahead with an advanced Pin-point Positioning™ System. Users can sketch the layout of the object on the software by marking a few points.

The S1 can engrave all sorts of surfaces, whether flat, curved, or cylindrical. Its 3D Curve Engraving™ Technology is designed to create a 3D model of the surface, dynamically adjusting the focus to engrave uneven and curved surfaces. For engraving on cylindrical objects, a separate attachment, the RA2 Pro, is also available.

The S1 is a Class 1 Laser Product, designed for home use with utmost safety. The machine comes with an enclosed casing that contains laser and exhaust fumes. No goggles are required as the machine features a laser filtering lid. Furthermore, there’s a lid-open safety stop button and a 5-direction flame alert in case of fire.

Using the S1 is simple with our beginner-friendly software, xTool Creative Space (XCS). You get access to 1000+ project ideas and tutorials for getting started. Support for the popular laser software Lightburn is also present.

Key Features:

• World’s Most Powerful Enclosed Diode Laser
• Available in 40W, 20W and 10W.
• 2W IR module for metal and plastics engraving
• Class 1 Laser Product
• Supports rotary and curved surface engraving

Best CO2 Laser Engraver and Cutter 

CNET, TomsHardware, CreativeBloq – all top reviewing sites have declared the xTool P2 as the best CO2 laser cutter and engraver. The P2 is a powerhouse with 55W optical power and top engraving speed of 600mm/s. It boasts better absorption efficiency than a diode laser and can cut through material three times quicker compared to a diode laser.

Internally, the machine is quite spacious, featuring a bed size of 26 by 14 inches. This can be further expanded with an automated passthrough slot that allows for working on objects up to 118 inches.

Inside, the P2 also has a dual 16MP camera system. They provide real-time views of the workspace and allow you to drag and drop designs directly onto the materials. Engraving on multiple objects, i.e., batch engraving, is also supported. Its intelligent DistiMaster™ Ranging System uses LIDAR technology to provide precise measurements, enabling more accurate cuts.

The P2 features CurveAce™ technology that enables it to work on curved and uneven surfaces. The machine creates a 3D model of objects and then maps the design directly onto the material surface.

With power comes the need for more caution, and knowing this, xTool has added multiple safety features in the P2. The machine automatically locks during operation and includes an emergency stop button, a multi-warning system, and an excellent exhaust system. Most importantly, the machine is fully enclosed, eliminating any risk of laser exposure. The P2 also comes with a fire safety kit – the world’s first kit in this category.

The xTool P2 is designed for a range of small businesses. Whether you're a woodworker looking to decorate and customize wooden items, a jewelry designer wanting to create stylish acrylic accessories, or an event planner wanting to personalize weddings and parties, xTool P2 is the best tool to have.

Key Features

• 55W CO2 laser module
• Top engraving speed of 600 mm/s
• Large bed size: 16 x 14 inches
• Dual 16MP camera system
• CurveAce technology for working on curved surfaces
• Supports Rotary Engraving

Conclusion

CO2, Fiber, and Diode lasers are different from each other in various aspects. The main difference is in their working principle. For a user, the difference is in the cost, materials they can cut/engrave, speed, lifespan, and power. For small businesses, a diode laser is a perfect option. If you want to work on such non-metals that are not compatible with diode lasers, you can use a CO2 laser. The fiber laser is excellent in terms of cutting metals, but it is not suitable for small businesses.

For more questions. Please join our Facebook group to get inspired!

Related Articles